News

Brutally binary: Time to axe ‘secure-fit’ Ofsted judgements

Can Ofsted raise standards while recognising school complexity? The answer lies beyond the rigid ‘secure fit’ model, argues Kerry Boffey

Recent criticisms from the profession on Ofsted’s new inspection framework should not be dismissed as resistance to accountability.

It is understandable that a number of trade unions is calling for graded inspections to be paused and there are reports that education secretary Lucy Powell has told the inspectorate to go back to the drawing board.

However, amid a growing crescendo of union anger following the publication by Ofsted (2026) of its own research on the impact of the reforms, the secretary of state drew a line in the sand at the Confederation of School Trusts conference by observing that Ofsted had played an important role in raising standards over the last 30 years and “it will continue to do so for the next 30 as well”.

With the inspectorate’s immediate future assured, the profession now needs to agree on what both ministers and Ofsted need to hear about the framework before anything changes.

To this end, there is something uncomfortable about the way inspection is sometimes discussed. Ofsted speaks, quite properly, about raising standards and securing better outcomes for children. But this can inadvertently suggest that Ofsted is the guardian of educational standards while everyone else is somehow waiting to be told what good education looks like.

That is simply not the reality. Headteachers care deeply about the quality of their schools. Teachers care about their pupils. Parents and carers want their children to be safe, happy and successful. Children themselves generally want to enjoy school, belong, learn and achieve. These people do not need an inspectorate to give them a reason to care about education.

The challenge, therefore, is not whether we need accountability. We do. The question is whether the methodology used to provide that accountability is capable of recognising the complexity of education while maintaining high expectations.

This is where Ofsted’s principle of “secure fit” deserves much greater scrutiny.

Click here to read the full article.

Tags

Our website uses cookies to provide you with a good browsing experience and to improve our website. For further information, view our Cookie & Privacy Policy.

We are committed to protecting your privacy and ensuring your data is handled in compliance with the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).